Judge Gregory M. Sleet recently transferred a case to the Central District of California, finding that all but two Jumara factors weighed in favor of transfer. Blackbird Tech LLC v. TuffStuff Fitness, International, Inc., C.A. No. 16-733-GMS (D. Del. Apr. 27, 2017). Judge Sleet explained that the plaintiff’s forum choice weighed in favor of maintaining the litigation in Delaware, but it did not warrant maximum deference because “Delaware is not its ‘home turf’ or principal place of business.” The Court found that the convenience of witnesses weighed against transfer, but only slightly. However, “several factors counsel transfer: the defendant’s choice of forum, convenience of the parties, location where the claim arose, the location of relevant books and records, and court congestion.” With respect to court congestion, the Court noted that the time to trial in the Central District of California was roughly five months shorter than that in Delaware, and the overall disposition time in the Central District of California was roughly four months shorter than in Delaware.
Blackbird Tech LLC v. TuffStuff Fitness Int’l, Inc., C.A. No. 16-733-GMS (D. Del. Apr. 27, 2017)